When is a Nazi salute not a Nazi salute? When Elon Musk does two

On BBC Newsnight the panel of journalists and politicians were discussing Elon Musk’s emphatic salute at US President Donald Trump’s triumphal inauguration rally in Washington.
Probably most people have seen Musk’s Dr Strangelove moment by now but none of the panel would say what it most clearly was: a Nazi salute.
Musk did not just involuntarily raise his right arm and point his fingers to heaven. He slammed his right hand into his chest, paused for a long moment, and then thrust his arm outwards as tens of millions watched nationwide, and thousands of Trump supporters in the auditorium cheered.
At this point, many people were no doubt watching stunned and wondering if they had just hallucinated Musk’s gesture, but helpfully, he then turned his back and did the same salute to those in the seats behind him.
And yet somehow Gabriel Gatehouse, a seasoned BBC observer of US politics and the far right, played down the moment, as did the great sword-carrying failed Conservative leadership contender Penny Mordaunt. Gatehouse suggested it could be a “Roman salute” and compared it to a cartoon frog that appeared in the 2016 presidential campaign.
New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch
Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters
The new Starmerite MP Alex Ballinger - a former Marine and ex-diplomat who appeared alongside them - only had warm words about the Labour government’s relations with Trump. This is despite Musk repeatedly accusing members of the Labour cabinet and Prime Minister Keir Starmer of extreme crimes such as enabling the “rape of Britain” and calling for its overthrow.
Pro-Israel group defends Musk
It seems the more that Musk makes it clear that he is the self-appointed leader of the global far right who wishes to see the toppling of governments and leaders he doesn’t like, the more centrist politicians bow and scrape for some kind of relations with the world’s richest man and the Trump administration he’s part of.
Of course, Labour has to have relations with the Trump regime, but the grovelling of Foreign Secretary David Lammy and others is proof, if any more was needed, of the bankruptcy of centrism in the face of the rise of fascism.
The pro-Israel Anti-Defamation League also came to the defence of Musk and downplayed the significance of the salute. “It seems that Elon Musk made an awkward gesture in a moment of enthusiasm, not a Nazi salute, but again, we appreciate that people are on edge. In this moment, all sides should give each other the benefit of the doubt, and take a breath. This is a new beginning.”
It appears that Musk's nod to the Third Reich is just a little misunderstanding among friends for a group obsessed with pro-Palestinian protests rather than the threat of genuine antisemitism.
As one X commentator put it in response to news headlines that left doubt about what Musk had done: “Apart from literally screaming out Zieg Heil! Musk *twice* and with tremendous enthusiasm, did the Third Reich salute. There’s no “appears”. It’s right there.”
During the rise of Hitler, many western politicians and businessmen dismissed the idea that the Nazi leader meant what he said, and claimed it was performative and that he was a perfectly reasonable fellow. These views were common among the British ruling elite right up to 1940 and the invasion of France.
Today, it may seem fun to see Musk’s Nazi salute as just a provocation to liberals, as Gatehouse suggests, but for victims of fascist violence and hate, it’s not really a laughing matter.
Real victims
Millions of migrants in the United States now face being rounded up under a Trump executive order. Many have spent most of their lives in the US, and their children were born there.
As Zara Mohammed of the Muslim Council of Britain put it, many young Muslims are experiencing a “deeply challenging time”, and are choosing to stay away from Musk’s toxic X platform and certain other social media sites. “It’s so hostile. It’s so disgusting I would say, the kind of vitriol we’re seeing.”
Trump’s inauguration comes as far-right parties are expected to win big in Germany in February, for the first time since 1945.
Musk is the personification of the 40-year failure of neoliberalism, now replaced by billionaire authoritarian rule
In the UK, jailed anti-Muslim campaigner Tommy Robinson has called for a march of the far right in London on 1 February. October’s neofascist march in London was attended by tens of thousands, rather than the few hundred football thugs that used to go to these events, usually outnumbered by anti-fascist counter-protesters. Meanwhile, a peaceful protest demanding an end to UK support for Israel’s genocide faced police kettling and mass arrests.
Musk’s salute was a message to all of the world’s far-right legions: now is our time. We will no longer need to disguise our beliefs about white supremacy and our goal to declare war on Global South minorities, especially Muslims, in western countries. The gloves are off.
And centrists do not want to see this, as they have largely enabled the far right to get into this position, with years of policies that created greater inequality and poverty in the West, while funding and supporting wars and genocide in the Middle East. Musk is the personification of the 40-year failure of neoliberalism, now replaced by billionaire authoritarian rule.
As another user on Musk’s X platform succinctly put it: “When they tell you who they are, believe them.”
The views expressed in this article belong to the author and do not necessarily reflect the editorial policy of Middle East Eye.
Middle East Eye delivers independent and unrivalled coverage and analysis of the Middle East, North Africa and beyond. To learn more about republishing this content and the associated fees, please fill out this form. More about MEE can be found here.