Skip to main content

Police raid Paris bookshop over children’s colouring book about Palestine

Police searched Violette and Co, a feminist and LGBTQIA+ bookstore, for copies of 'From the River to the Sea', prompting accusations of censorship
Social Bandit Media, publisher of children's colouring book 'From the River to the Sea', said they made the French-language version of the book available for free download online, arguing that there is no formal ban on its sale or distribution (Social Bandit Media)
Social Bandit Media, publisher of children's colouring book 'From the River to the Sea', said they made the French-language version of the book available for free download online, arguing that there is no formal ban on its sale or distribution (Social Bandit Media)

French police raided a feminist and LGBTQIA+ bookshop in Paris in early January in an operation targeting a children’s colouring book about Palestine.

On 7 January, five uniformed police officers, accompanied by a prosecutor, searched Violette and Co, a well-known queer bookshop, in an attempt to seize copies of From the River to the Sea: A Colouring Bookthe bookshop's owners announced on Friday.

The raid marked a sharp escalation from the summer, when the same title triggered far-right vandalism and threats against the shop, as well as a heated public debate about pro-Palestinian censorship in France.

The book by South African author and illustrator Nathi Ngubane explores Palestinian history and culture, the ongoing Israeli occupation and Palestinian resistance movements.

The Paris prosecutor confirmed that the operation followed a referral by the Ministry of the Interior, which denounced what it described as the book's "strong historical and ideological bias". 

New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch

Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters

The bookshop’s lawyer denounced the operation as "illegal and disproportionate". 

Thibault Laforcade said the October recommendation to ban imports of the book by the Commission for the Surveillance and Control of Publications for Youth (CSCPJ) was a political position "without legal foundation", adding that only the Interior Ministry could issue a formal ban. 

The bookshop said it was only informed after the raid of the unfavourable advisory opinion.

According to the bookshop, the search lasted around 45 minutes. Officers inspected shelves, storage rooms and boxes of books while wearing body cameras and prevented customers from entering. 

No copies of the book were found or seized, as it was no longer in stock - Violette and Co said they had sold all of their copies by September.

The bookstore’s staff have been summoned for questioning later this month as part of a police investigation.  

'Repressive obscenity'

In a statement following the raid, Violette and Co said it constituted an unprecedented police intervention in an independent cultural space and denounced what it called a form of political policing.

In a separate press release, the publisher, Social Bandit Media, rejected accusations that the children's book was "likely to incite hatred" against Israelis and "harm the moral development of young people". It also criticised what it described as a de facto censorship procedure against a publication that remains legal.

The raid also sparked widespread criticism across political, cultural and online communities, many of whom condemned the raid as an attack on freedom of expression. 

Several elected officials pointed to what they see as a pattern of pressure on the bookshop, citing political attacks and vandalism last summer, attempts to cut its public funding and now a police search.

Online, many users expressed disbelief that police and prosecutors had been mobilised to look for a children’s colouring book, calling the scene "surreal" and deeply worrying for cultural freedoms. 

Translation: Enough is enough! The bookshop "Violette and Co" has been raided. And the complaint it filed over the threats it has been facing has disappeared. Unbearable pressure on independent bookshops. In the face of attacks from the right and Macronists, let's mobilise! 

Others denounced what they described as an authoritarian drift in French politics and the use of judicial tools to intimidate independent, politically engaged spaces.

"This is an unprecedented act in a cultural venue in France, and of extreme gravity," said Clemence Guette, deputy of the French National Assembly. "I express my support for the employees of the bookstore and I call for a wake-up: the anti-democratic and authoritarian drift of Macronism, particularly on the issue of the genocide in Palestine, is alarming."

Translation: Repressive obscenity. "Violette and Co." isn't just a bookstore: it's you and me, it's our rights. Five cops and a deputy prosecutor came down to all of our homes this morning.

Some social media users linked the affair to broader legislative debates, notably the proposed "Yadan bill" on combating "renewed forms of antisemitism". 

Critics of the draft law warn that it could further restrict freedom of expression, particularly around criticism of Israel and Israeli policy.

Some argued that the raid of Violette and Co demonstrates that such constraints are already being enforced.

Middle East Eye delivers independent and unrivalled coverage and analysis of the Middle East, North Africa and beyond. To learn more about republishing this content and the associated fees, please fill out this form. More about MEE can be found here.