Skip to main content

Egypt ignored paperwork of US citizen who died in prison, lawyer says

Cairo took no action after Moustafa Kassem renounced his Egyptian citizenship after entering into an agreement that would see him deported to the US
Since Abdel Fattah el-Sisi came to power, as many as 60,000 dissidents have been jailed in Egypt (Courtesy of Kassem family)

Egypt repeatedly ignored paperwork that could have allowed a US citizen who died in prison earlier this month from being released, his lawyer and a Democratic senator have said.

Moustafa Kassem, a dual Egyptian-American citizen, was arrested in Cairo in August 2013 following a military coup that brought Abdel Fattah el-Sisi to power.

Kassem had insisted he was wrongfully detained by Egyptian soldiers when he was at a shopping centre near Cairo's Rabaa al-Adawiya square.

'President Trump's complete disregard for human rights abroad clearly sent a signal to Sisi and others that they don't have to take American requests on these issues seriously'

- Senator Chris Murphy

After spending more than five years in pretrial detention, he was later sentenced to 15 years in jail in a mass trial involving hundreds of defendants.

He wrote letters to both US President Donald Trump and Vice President Mike Pence asking them to secure his freedom, but died on 14 January after a series of hunger strikes.

Stay informed with MEE's newsletters

Sign up to get the latest alerts, insights and analysis, starting with Turkey Unpacked


His lawyer, Praveen Madhiraju, told NBC News on Thursday that Kassem had dropped his appeal against his conviction and submitted papers to relinquish his Egyptian citizenship more than six months ago.

The decision was based on an agreement with Egypt that would see him deported to the US.

But according to his lawyer, Egypt took no action, despite Pence speaking with the country's foreign minister in December.

The administration raised the issue, "but they didn't do everything they could have", Madhiraju told NBC.

'Extremely troubled'

"I'm extremely troubled that the Egyptian government chose to sit on the paperwork to release Mustafa Kassem for months, essentially sealing his fate to die in their prisons," Democratic Senator Chris Murphy of Connecticut said in a statement to NBC.

Sisi has overseen "a brutal crackdown on political dissent", Murphy said. "But President Trump's complete disregard for human rights abroad clearly sent a signal to Sisi and others that they don't have to take American requests on these issues seriously."

Moustafa Kassem's death was due to 'failures by the Trump administration'
Read More »

The White House and State Department were not immediately available for comment.

Since 2013, Sisi's government has overseen a broad crackdown against dissent, with as many as 60,000 people jailed.

While members of the Muslim Brotherhood - to which former President Mohamed Morsi belonged - were the main target, secular and left-wing activists have also been imprisoned.

Kassem's brother-in-law, Mustafa Ahmed, had previously described conditions at the maximum security Tora prison, where he was kept, as dire.

"The cells are filthy, infested with insects, rodents and snakes," he wrote in an op-ed for The New York Times last year. 

"They have no ventilation, sun or light. Kassem and the other prisoners have no access to clean water, a bed, a chair or any books."

Still, Trump has repeatedly heaped praise on the Egyptian leader, even calling him "my favourite dictator".

While the US has cut aid to Egypt in the past, citing human rights concerns, the Trump administration has waived human rights conditions that have applied to some $300m in aid.

Egypt is the second-biggest recipient of US military aid after Israel, receiving $1.3bn every year.

Middle East Eye delivers independent and unrivalled coverage and analysis of the Middle East, North Africa and beyond. To learn more about republishing this content and the associated fees, please fill out this form. More about MEE can be found here.