Skip to main content

'Hamas is Hamas is Hamas': How MP spoke up for Israel in parliament

Former assistant to Robert Halfon told undercover reporter she placed Commons question to then-prime minister David Cameron in 2014
Robert Halfon speaks at Prime Minister's Questions on 2 July 2014 (YouTube)

British government minister Robert Halfon has talked about Israel on 65 occasions in the House of Commons since he was elected as the member of parliament for Harlow in 2010, according to Hansard, the official parliamentary record.

In a secret recording by an undercover Al Jazeera reporter shared with Middle East Eye, Halfon's former parliamentary assistant, Maria Strizzolo, who had connections to the Israeli embassy in London and the Israeli Ministry of Strategic Affairs, revealed details of how she had used her position to place parliamentary statements sympathetic to Israel.

REVEALED: Secret tapes expose Israeli influence over UK Conservative Party

Describing how questions were planted with MPs, Strizzolo said: "You know, you brief them, you say: 'You don't have to do anything, we are going to give you the speech, we are going to give you all the information, we are going to do everything for you'."

She claimed to have influenced Halfon, currently a junior education minister and a former Conservative Party deputy chairman, to ask a question concerning the abduction and killing of three Israeli teenagers in the occupied West Bank in July 2014.

On 2 July 2014, Halfon asked then-prime minister David Cameron the following question:

"The world has seen the tragic and brutal murders of three Israeli youngsters, most probably by Hamas. Will my right honourable friend give the Israeli Government every possible support at this time? Does he agree that, far from showing restraint, Israel must do everything possible to take out Hamas terrorist networks, and will he give the Israeli Government support in that?"

Below is a selection of some of Halfon's other statements made in parliament in relation to Israel.

On Labour MP Gerald Kaufman's 'hatred of Israel'

I must say that his hatred for Israel knows no bounds. He explains exactly why universal jurisdiction [Kaufman had opposed proposed changes to a law that had seen Israeli politicians threatened with arrest over suspected war crimes if they visited the UK] needs to be changed - it is being used as a political football by people such as him who have hidden agendas. (13 December 2010)

On 'extreme Islam'

The objective of extreme Islamists is not a peaceful resolution to the Middle East situation, but jihad; it is an ideology that believes that Israel and, by extension, Jews should be wiped off the map. [Then-Iranian] President Ahmadinejad makes no local distinction between the West Bank and Tel Aviv. It is the catch-all Zionist entity that must be destroyed…

The poison of extreme Islamism is not something that can be talked into submission or bubble-wrapped in bureaucracy. Its imams are preaching the most ideological and embittered form of anti-Semitism in the UK. The fundamental right of Israel to exist and of Jewish families to live in peace should not be a matter for debate.  (20 January 2011)

On Israel as a 'bulwark of freedom'

Our current policy towards Israel should be much more supportive. Criticism of Israel is out of all proportion to that of other countries. It is always incredible how everyone wants to be a candid friend of Israel but no one is a candid friend of France, Germany or America. Yes, of course Israel is imperfect, and yes, there are problems with settlements, but the fact is that in a region of dictators, Israel is a bulwark of freedom. The excuse is often given that Israel-Palestine is the driving force behind all conflict in the Middle East, but recent events have disproved that.

I believe that peace would happen incredibly quickly in Israel with two states - a Palestinian state and an Israeli state - if Arabist dictators stopped funding terrorism. The more democratic these countries become, the less likely there is to be a war. I do not think there is an example in history of two democracies that have fought each other. I have often met Palestinian moderates who have the will to make peace, but not the authority, whereas Hamas, sadly, has the authority but not the will.  (17 March 2011)

OBORNE: Alan Duncan's opposition to settlements makes him Israeli target

On Israel's security barrier

Does the honourable gentleman recognise that far from being a wall, what he is describing is a fence, a tiny proportion of which is wall? Does he recognise that the reason it was built in the first place was to prevent suicide bombers from coming into Israel on a daily basis? That is something that it fortunately has achieved. (26 March 2012, addressed to Labour MP Alex Cunningham)

On Iran as the 'Soviet Union of the Middle East'

Many people regard Iran as the Soviet Union of the Middle East, because it practises repression at home, it exports terrorism abroad and it says it wants to wipe Israel off the map. How will my right honourable friend judge whether this is genuine perestroika and glasnost or whether it is deception by Iran, and what steps can he take to ensure that over the six months it not only stops work on nuclear enrichment, but stops supporting Hamas, Hezbollah and the Assad regime? (25 November 2013 addressed to then-foreign secretary William Hague)

On the effectiveness of Israel's Iron Dome missile defence system

Are we not in a crazy situation where Israel is being criticised for defending itself too well, because the Iron Dome is stopping many of the missiles and preventing many thousands of Israeli citizens from being killed?  (17 July 2014)

COMMENT: Israel's anti-BDS campaign: Propaganda and dirty tricks

On parallels between Hamas and IS

I thank my right honourable friend for his statement that Israel was right to defend itself against the missile barrage from Hamas. Does he agree that the difference between Hamas and ISIS is one of degrees? Does he also agree that Iran remains a serious security threat and that our enemy's enemy is not our friend? (1 September 2014, addressed to Prime Minister David Cameron)

On Jordan as a 'Palestinian state'

I agree that there should be a Palestinian state. In fact, not many realise that there is already a Palestinian state called Jordan. It was created by the British in 1921 and was originally called Transjordan. After the 1948-49 war against the newly created state of Israel, the Jordanian monarch, Abdullah, even called himself the King of Jordan and Palestine, as his country controlled the West Bank.

The vast majority of Arabs currently in Jordan are in fact Palestinians ruled by a monarch from the Hashemite minority. Before the 1967 Six Day War when Israel defeated the Arab invasion and took control of the West Bank and Gaza, which had been under the arm of Egypt, there had never been demands from Palestinians in the disputed territories for a second Palestinian state, as they were under Jordanian rule.

Today's motion to recognise a second Palestinian state… overlooks the fact that the Palestinians in the west bank and the Palestinians in Gaza are ruled by entirely different entities—the more moderate Fatah and the terrorist organisation Hamas. If we are not careful, we could end up with three Palestinian states, or to be precise one state and two statelets: one controlled by the Hashemite Kingdom in Jordan, the eastern borders of which are now threatened by ISIS; one controlled by Fatah in the west bank; and one controlled by Hamas in Gaza. (13 October 2014)

On 'taking out' Hamas

Hamas is Hamas is Hamas: it is a terrorist organisation whether it is part of the so-called [Palestinian] unity government or not… Surely it is now time to cut off relations with the Government given that they are co-opted with a terrorist organisation. Does my right honourable friend agree that, far from showing restraint, the British Government should give Israel every possible assistance to take out the Hamas terrorist network so that that country can be sure that her children will be secure in the future? (1 July 2014, addressed to then-foreign office minister Hugh Robertson)

This article is available in French on Middle East Eye French edition.

Stay informed with MEE's newsletters

Sign up to get the latest alerts, insights and analysis, starting with Turkey Unpacked

Middle East Eye delivers independent and unrivalled coverage and analysis of the Middle East, North Africa and beyond. To learn more about republishing this content and the associated fees, please fill out this form. More about MEE can be found here.