Skip to main content

'This is violence': Hungary denounces EU migrant plan

PM Viktor Orban says European Union forcing Hungary to become immigrant country 'against the will of the Hungarian people'
Migrant family at motorway border crossing of Roszke between Hungary and Serbia in April (AFP)

Hungary's Prime Minister Viktor Orban on Thursday launched a fresh attack on an EU plan to share thousands of migrants around the bloc, saying that forcing his country to partake in the scheme bordered on "violence".

The comments came a day after the European Court of Justice, the bloc's top court, rejected a legal challenge to the relocation plan lodged by Hungary and Slovakia.

They also followed criticism by EU chief Jean-Claude Juncker, who earlier this week chided Budapest for demanding extra money for border security while refusing to partake in the mandatory migrant redistribution scheme.

"Solidarity is not an à-la-carte dish," Juncker had said in a letter to Orban on Tuesday.

The Hungarian leader, who has previously called immigration the "Trojan Horse of terrorism," said he was "stunned and puzzled" by Juncker's response.

More than 400,000 people, many fleeing war in Syria, crossed through Hungary in 2015 (AFP)
"The interpretation of the principle of solidarity described in your letter is in essence the transformation of Hungary into an immigrant country, against the will of the Hungarian people," Orban said in a letter to Juncker, published on the government's website on Thursday.

"In my view, this is not solidarity, this is violence."  

Unlike other European Union member states, Hungary did not have a "colonial past," Orban added.

"These major member states have become immigrant countries, due to the obligations stemming from their colonial legacy," the populist strongman said.

"Hungary on the other hand... does not want to become an immigrant country and cannot accept being forced to change this."

Migrants call for freedom from Greek detention centres: 'I was forgotten here'
Read More »

More than 400,000 people, many fleeing war in Syria, crossed through Hungary in 2015 as they sought to reach Western and Northern Europe.

In response, Budapest erected fences on its southern borders with Serbia and Croatia and recruited 3,000 special "border hunter" police to patrol the frontiers.

The measures slowed the influx of migrants to a trickle, until the so-called "Balkan Route" northwards from Greece was effectively closed in March 2016.

Hungary's fences drew fierce criticism from Brussels, though other EU member states later built their own versions.

On 31 August, Orban wrote to Juncker asking that the EU refund half the $950m Hungary says it has spent on the borders.

In his latest letter, he reiterated his request.

"The fence and Hungarian border-hunters are not only protecting Hungarians, but Austrian, German and other European Union citizens as well," Orban said.

Juncker insisted earlier this week he and the European Commission "remain committed" to working with Hungary toward a more efficient and fairer migration policy.

Stay informed with MEE's newsletters

Sign up to get the latest alerts, insights and analysis, starting with Turkey Unpacked

Middle East Eye delivers independent and unrivalled coverage and analysis of the Middle East, North Africa and beyond. To learn more about republishing this content and the associated fees, please fill out this form. More about MEE can be found here.