Skip to main content

Why Israel should stop trying to Judaise al-Quds

The holy city's Arab Palestinian character is an important part of its world-renowned diversity
Palestinians pray at al-Aqsa Mosque compound (AFP)

My parents are from the Arab Palestinian city of al-Quds, not Jerusalem. While I was not born there, my first visit was a year or two after it was occupied in 1967. 

My early memories of al-Quds are of meeting family who spoke Arabic with the same accent and of playing with cousins. When I got a little older, I would be tasked with taking a dish down the hill to be filled with delicious hummus, and calling on the baker for bagels and fresh falafel. What a breakfast that was. 

I remember walking through the Old City, through Damascus Gate, through the Arab souq and all the way to al-Aqsa Mosque to pray without impediment. I did not see any flags, Palestinian nor Israeli. I visited my family’s graves in the nearby cemetery, too. We have roots.

A ‘shy’ occupation

The occupation was not “in your face” in those days, as there were very few symbols of it. It seemed to be a “shy” occupation; perhaps the Israelis thought that it would not last.

Stay informed with MEE's newsletters

Sign up to get the latest alerts, insights and analysis, starting with Turkey Unpacked


Looking back now, I do not recall coming into contact with any Jews in that area. I remember that the Palestinians I interacted with resented the occupation, but hoped and believed it would end soon.

I broke down when I saw the Palestinian flag flying a short distance out from the border post, where only Israeli flags were flown

How wrong they were. Not only has the occupation been entrenched across the whole of the West Bank, but al-Quds has suffered exceptionally.

From day one, Israel had no plans to relinquish it for peace; it formally annexed it.

It set about changing the look and feel of the place through a series of policies and processes that would, over time, reduce its Arab Palestinian character and increase its Jewish character. 

My visits to al-Quds ceased for some 25 years. I returned after the Oslo Accords were signed, and hopes were high. Armed with my British passport, I was greeted with “welcome to Israel”. I broke down when I saw the Palestinian flag flying a short distance out from the border post, where only Israeli flags were flown.

I so much wanted to get to al-Quds. The notorious Qalandia checkpoint was not a structure as it is now. The city was reachable by Palestinians, and certainly for me, as a British “tourist” in my homeland.

Threat of division

It quickly dawned on me that this was not the city I had last visited a quarter-century ago. The occupation was more visible, with a much more present army and Israeli police - but also many Jews in areas that were wholly Palestinian Arab only 25 years before. The occupation was much more “in your face”. 

The very fabric of al-Quds - infrastructural, demographic and social - had changed, and continues to change. Ask a Palestinian from the great city how he or she thinks it has changed, and you see a shake of the head, a sign of despair at what has been and continues to happen. 

They tell you it is being Judaised at an alarming rate.

They ask how it is that those who came from outside Palestine have not only settled in their city, but now think it belongs to them and them alone. How can they call it their capital but deny us the right to call it our capital too?

Israeli police detain a Palestinian demonstrator at al-Aqsa compound on 18 February (AFP)
Israeli police detain a Palestinian demonstrator at al-Aqsa compound on 18 February (AFP)

They worry about al-Haram al-Sharif, home to al-Aqsa Mosque and the iconic, golden Dome of the Rock. They feel that the daily, unwelcome and provocative break-ins by Jewish settlers, protected by Israeli security forces, are meant to tell them that even the holy site is under threat of being divided or taken over. 

They point to Silwan, a short walk from the southern wall of the holy sanctuary - a Palestinian neighbourhood that Israeli settlers have targeted for years, as they claim it to be in or near the “City of David”.

Its Palestinian population has suffered home demolitions for “lack of building permits,” and evictions as settler groups use underhanded, yet “legal” means to take their homes. 

The demographic balance of Palestinians to Jewish settlers is being changed in favour of the settlers. 

Illegal settlements

To add insult to injury, the municipality recently approved the naming of streets in this Palestinian Arab neighbourhood, not after Arab scholars, but after Jewish rabbis. This is part of a deliberate attempt to Judaise the area. Young Palestinians will grow up knowing the streets not by their Arab names, but by the Hebrew Jewish rabbi names.

Bulldozing history: How Israel uses archaeology to entrench occupation
Read More »

Illegal settlements have been planted in other Palestinian Arab areas.

Hundreds of thousands of illegal settlers now live in the occupied Palestinian territory. A large Israeli flag flies in Attur (the Mount of Olives), overlooking the holy sanctuary. 

In March, the municipality posted notices, according to a local source, demanding that Palestinians stop all building work and visit its offices to discuss their possible “illegal” building, as most would have built without permits due to the city’s deliberate policy - over decades - of refusing them.

To control the demography of al-Quds, Israel built part of the separation wall to exclude a number of neighbourhoods - placing them outside the wall and making it easy to transfer the residents’ status to residing within Palestinian Authority areas. 

Israel also forces a Palestinian from al-Quds who decides to marry a Palestinian from the West Bank or Gaza to either move out to be with their partner, or sneak them in “illegally,” making it difficult for them to live a normal family life. It does not provide Jewish Israelis with the same dilemma. 

Israel has also cancelled thousands of residency permits for Palestinians from Jerusalem as another means of reducing its non-Jewish population.

Changing character

Israel also interferes in the education of Palestinian children, feeding them its own narrative about the city and land they live in. 

The indigenous Palestinians, Jews, Christians and Muslims who inhabited Palestine from the river to the sea at the turn of the last century, understand the significance of Jerusalem to millions around the world. 

Leave al-Quds alone, for everyone’s sake. Let its look and feel reflect its people

Those whose families - including mine - have lived in the city for centuries and are part of its fabric, whether Muslim or Christian, are not attempting to change its character.

This is what Israel is doing, and the process is accelerating, particularly under the biased US administration.

Instead of Judaising its Arab Palestinian part, Israel should work with Palestinians to jealously protect al-Quds' diversity - for that is a major part of its appeal to the world.

Let the Christian bells ring and the Muslim adhan sound in its skies alongside Jewish prayer, and educate Jewish Israelis to accept that. 

Telling them it is only “the Jewish people’s eternal undivided capital” is wrong. It belongs to the world.

Let it evolve naturally, as it has for centuries - and if you want to build a new Jewish Temple, build it away from al-Aqsa Mosque and the Church of the Holy Sepulchre.

Leave al-Quds alone, for everyone’s sake. Let its look and feel reflect its people.

The views expressed in this article belong to the author and do not necessarily reflect the editorial policy of Middle East Eye.

Kamel Hawwash is a British-Palestinian engineering professor based at the University of Birmingham. He is chair of the Palestine Solidarity Campaign (PSC) and a founding member of the British Palestinian Committee (BPC).
Middle East Eye delivers independent and unrivalled coverage and analysis of the Middle East, North Africa and beyond. To learn more about republishing this content and the associated fees, please fill out this form. More about MEE can be found here.